From TiVo and TimeWarner: A cattleman and his spoiled wife watch an upstart oilman try to take over Texas.
Original Drewssentials air date: April 27, 2013
Drew: This is such an interesting film to discuss because it’s such a high-caliber, important film. Um, I mean, this is sort of, you know, Film Study 101: you must watch GIANT.
Robert: Right. You got George Stevens, if for no other reason one should see this because of George Stevens, all the wonderful movies he made, and this is certainly part, an important part, of his catalog. And he won the Academy Award for it.
Drew: And only one who won an Academy Award, out of how many nominations?
Robert: Yes, ten nominations (Drew: yeah) and this was the only, uh, actual, his was the only win among them. But, he was the one in charge of the whole thing. It’s such an epic story, it’s uh, uh, based on a book by Edna Ferber, who wrote CIMARRON and SHOW BOAT, and, you know, DINNER AT EIGHT, and a lot of great things. But, I think it’s one of those epics that is very imposing in all ways. (Drew: yeah) They shot it on location, but it feels big. And, it’s about a big state, and it’s about big people. I mean, it’s just big all the way through. I have one objection to it, and that’s I think it’s too long. It, it was in that era when …
Drew: Three-and-a-half hours.
Robert: Three-and-a-half hours. And it’s in that one of that eras when, when movies were all being, uh, shown on road show, so they wanted to give customers who were paying more money to see it more movie, and, uh, it’s a long sit. But it’s got beautiful people in it, and it’s got very good actors in it: Elizabeth Taylor, Rock Hudson, James Dean, and then wonderful people like Mercedes McCambridge, Carroll Baker, …
Drew: Dennis Hopper…
Robert: Dennis Hopper,
Drew: Sal Mineo.
Robert: Sal Mineo. I mean it’s really loaded with talented people.
Drew: You’re right, everything is big scale: Texas, and oil, and, you know, the whole span of this family’s, uh, story, and yet it has the intimacy of a play in the fact that it takes place in so few locations, and, in, you know, in such a, so much in the house as well.
Robert: And it has poignancy to it, too, from the standpoint that James Dean, this was the last film he made, because it was like 2 weeks after they finished filming that he was killed in the car accident. And, uh, Rock Hudson, you know, who died much too young, this was like the most important film he did, and it shows what a really impressive leading man he could be when he had good material. He’s got a strong role, everybody wanted to play it, but he’s big like the title, and, uh, he’s very good in it.
Drew: Yes! And I also admire Elizabeth Taylor for not letting on that James Dean was the most cool, beautiful man on the planet.(1) (Robert: yeah) You know, she seems, uh, so wonderfully loyal and determined, you know, to make her marriage work, and to figure out the ups and downs of marriage, that the sign of the times with the way that men and women had their dynamics in the household, and there’s James Dean. I personally would have been falling all over myself (2), but I, I just thought it was amazing how they didn’t sort of, like, overplay their chemistry. Um, that you felt like this was the unit, her and Rock Hudson (Robert: right), where they’re trying to, you know, find their way.
Robert: Well, after the movie, I also want to talk a little about Elizabeth Taylor; I don’t want to talk about this before the movie, but just see what you think about something. Uh, I have an idea about this.
Drew: Ok.
Robert: Ok, is that alright?
Drew: I’m looking forward to it.
Robert: Ok, we’ll do…well, let’s watch the movie right now. Here it is, a sprawling drama based on the novel by Edna Ferber, from Warner Brothers in 1956: GIANT.
(1) Part of me always wonders if James Dean would have the same reputation today if he’d lived. The fact that he died young, in a car accident, and after only three movies, has (IMO) led him to be lionized in a way that I’m not so sure would have happened if his career had stretched over a few decades. Maybe he would still be a legend, and maybe his vices (of which there were allegedly many) would have ended up destroying him, as they did to so many others. (Montgomery Clift is the first example that comes to mind.)
(2) Drew, how many times do we have to go over this, it’s called ACTING. The ‘impressive’ thing is not the fact that Elizabeth Taylor managed to keep her panties on while she was around James Dean, it’s her performance, because, you know: ACTING.